Login | Create A Free Account | FAQ
WindyCitizen.com HomeBlogsAdvertise Find People
Popular Latest Links Comments
Max shared a link...
12

Sweet Home Chicago

youtube.com - 5 weeks ago - 237 views
Watermark image


The legendary Robert Johnson.

Read full story »

Post a comment E-mail it Tweet it Facebook it

13 Comments Have your say. Vote up the best responses. ↓

Comments

I think maybe this is amateur film shot around Maxwell Street but there's no indication. Anyway, if it was, it would be great, because Maxwell Street had huge significance to the Chicago blues. At any rate, an interesting collage!

3 points
by BradFlora 5 weeks 5 days ago

I like this version of the song so much better than the "wailing fat white guy" version you usually hear at festivals and on the radio.

2 points
by LAZ 5 weeks 5 days ago

LOL! This is the original.

1 points
by BradFlora 5 weeks 5 days ago

I assumed as much, but you know what I mean, right? Is the version I loathe from the Blues Brothers or something?

2 points
by Max 5 weeks 5 days ago

Here's the "wailing fat white guy" version from the 1980 film. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h9hdiUuSgIc

I read a skinny book on Johnson a while back, which sure doesn't make me an expert, but I don't know if one can state, strictly speaking, that a lot of early blues songs are "original". There was a repertoire that the musicians passed around and embellished; I think this may have been one that was a collaborative effort. But surely this version is the "original" in the sense that Johnson totally owns it; it has become a cliché - it's such a great song because of the stamp that he puts on it. [Side note to Brad Flora: I love how I can go back and correct my spelling errors here!]

2 points
by Len Kody 5 weeks 4 days ago

I like this rough, pure, authentic Mississippi Blues version of the tune best, too.

But let's not pile on the classic (if, some might agree, slightly inferior) Blues Bros. rendition. It only does what all of Chicago Blues does to Mississippi Blues - preforming the old standard with electrified instruments and a distinctly urban bombast.


On a mission from god

And with the original, Robert Johnson song as musician/blues aficionado Dan Aykroyd and natural born performer/Chicagoan John Belushi's sole source of inspiration, I'd say without a moment's hesitation that the 1980 effort to pay a broad shouldered homage to this fundamental component of our American culture - born of the joys and sorrows in the folkloric cauldron of the Deep South, and brought to northern cities on the rails of industry and technology that would become inseparably incorporated into the Chicago Blues sound - is worthy of its enduring success.


Robert Johnson

No less worthy, I suppose, than bands like the Rolling Stones and Led Zeppelin who where in the vanguard of an especially lucrative period for the dearly departed American record industry known as the British Invasion of the 1960's. The unceasing succession of hit singles that created the soundtrack of the Baby Boomers' lives were all heavily influenced by that irresistible, down home Delta Blues.


They intentionally composed their music to be the most difficult levels to beat on Guitar Hero

The problem with subsequent and far too ubiquitous versions of "Sweet Home Chicago," versions awkwardly belted out as a surefire crowd-pleaser by "wailing fat white" hack bands on an open mic under the neon lights of Old Style signs at dive bars, or sung in drunken chorus by tailgaters reveling in victory or, more commonly, defeat in Soldier Field's parking lot, is the degradation of the "Xerox effect": a copy of a copy of a copy.

Significant degradation, in this case.

Because, like the kid who thought he'd just rent the movie to write his book report, the more commonly heard versions of the windy city blues tribute are treating the homage as source material.

Those fools are trying to sing it like Joliet Jake and Elwood Blues.

Even so, I argue that the Blues Bros. version, while not the pure and authentic expression of Delta Blues that is Robert Johnson's "Sweet Home Chicago," Aykroyd and Belushi's is undoubtedly a pure and authentic reaction to the original, with merit enough on its own to echo through the popular consciousness for nearly 3 decades to fulfill here, today, in this thread, on this website, what can only be its highest calling - serving as a bridge of familiarity and a gateway to the appreciation of a piece of crackling, 73 year-old audio otherwise destined to be a misplaced and forgotten national treasure.

Well, there's this movie also, which I happen to know inspired a guy that happens to be a fabulous harp player and teacher.

1 points
by Len Kody 5 weeks 4 days ago

Whoa. Directed by Walter Hill AND a climactic guitar duel with the devil. Adding to Netflix queue...

Gotta admit, though, Ralph Macchio in the lead role has me skeptical. Without the crane kick that pony don't have too many tricks left.

AND very fresh-faced and lovely Jamie Gertz.... :D
I thought the guitar duel was a little too heavy metal for my taste but whatever.

-1 points
by qstrian 5 weeks 5 days ago

Notice the El tracks in the background? Kellogg's Rice Krispies billboard? Mixed racial & ethnicity?

Shills are missing from the shop entrances to take advantage of some special retail offer. That's what makes me doubt that it's a Maxwell Streescape.

The video and Johnson's original recording of this song are indeed spectacular. I must confess however, that I also like the "wailing fat guy" version. Ackroyd and Belushi have what is essentially the "MG's" backing them, these guys were players on hundreds of Stax recordings and are arguably as important to the Stax sound as The Funk Brothers are to Motown. Additionally, Johnson's version is not the "sole source of inspiration" for The Blues Brothers version, the dedication at the beginning of the performance tells us as much. They are sending a tribute to Magic Sam who also did a "plugged in" version of the song that you'll find the Blues Brothers version sounding a lot closer to than the Johnson version. Here's that version:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ow7OvsQtVQc

It appears on Magic Sam's Windy City Soul. A must own album in my estimation.

1 points
by Len Kody 5 weeks 4 days ago

Thanks for the insight and the link, Chas! Willis Tower Ups to you.

Man, I think I'm falling in love with this thread.

Who else is going to listen to all three tracks in a row, now? I know I will more than once.

Plug in the ear buds and trace the course of the tune through its entire musicological evolution: jook joint to John Landis.

I love stuff like that.

Like when I have the time or if it's the right occasion to indulge in a mini movie marathon, I'll throw in Yojimbo by Akira Kurosawa, Fistful of Dollars by Sergio Leone, then Last Man Standing by Walter Hill and do pretty much the same thing. (There's Walter Hill again. How the heck did that happen?)

Post new comment

To join the conversation create a profile, login, or
Reactions on the web
Latest tweets linking to this story (Share url: http://windycitizen.com/wer0)

Latest News from our Sponsors [?]

Paid for and Authorized by Friends of Dan Hynes

12 Chicagoans voted up this post

  • ChicagoChas
  • ChicagoBankerMan
  • qstrian
  • Disaffected
  • Len Kody

Explore this story


This site Copyright 2009, Windy Citizen.com - All rights reserved. Content posted by users is dedicated to the public domain.
Designed in Chicago's Old Town neighborhood.